Beyond the Scoreboard · Cinematic Ink

The Route Tree

One historical question. Two alternative assignments. Complete the version your teacher assigns—you do not need to do both.

Two balanced evidence setsSeparate saving and Turn InSame writing target

Choose your assignment.

Authentic photograph of Johnny Unitas at Harborplace, Maryland, January 20, 1996.
Documentary photograph · 1996

Johnny Unitas, beyond the setback.

This is a verified later portrait of Unitas, not a photograph of his 1955 sandlot season.

Photo: John Mathew Smith / Kingkongphoto, CC BY-SA 2.0. Photograph and license record.

A

Find the open door

A more guided evidence trail, with answer-building supports.

Your five NFL cases: Johnny Unitas, Vince Papale, Michael Lewis, Antonio Gates, Jordan Mailata.

5 NFL + 1 other sport3 responses · about 300 words35–45 minutes
Open Assignment A
Authentic September 3, 1953 Los Angeles Daily News photograph of Night Train Lane, number 81, recovering a fumble.
Original press photograph · 1953

Night Train Lane, number 81.

This photograph records a September 3, 1953 Rams–49ers preseason play, not Lane's 1952 tryout.

Los Angeles Daily News, U.S. public domain; territorial restrictions may apply. Photograph and license record.

B

Test the explanation

A more independent case file, with synthesis, source criticism and counterargument.

Your five NFL cases: Night Train Lane, Rocky Bleier, Kurt Warner, Stephen Neal, Brandon Aubrey.

5 NFL + 1 other sport3 responses · about 300 words35–45 minutes
Open Assignment B

Balanced workload, different thinking.

TaskAB
NFL cases55
Other sport11
Evidence calls55
Written responses3 × 90–110 words3 × 90–110 words
ApproachGuided comparisonIndependent argument

Both investigate how preparation, opportunity and setbacks shape an unexpected route. The reading and writing loads are matched; B raises the reasoning demand rather than adding more pages.